themoosejthm: (Default)
 Modern AU's taking place in the United States? Totally fine, not erasing culture. Hogwarts AU's? Totally fine, not erasing culture. Victorian Europe AU's? Totally fine, not erasing culture. American Christian AU's? Totally fine, not erasing culture. Non cultivator AU's? Totally fine, not erasing culture. Jewish AU's? WHOA, WHOA, HOLD UP! STOP ERASING THEIR CULTURE!

 Hmmm....Well, I mean, that's a good point. You really shouldn't replace one culture with another, that is really intensive and not cool. And just because it's been done by other people, doesn't mean the people seeing YOUR work know about them or haven't said anything about the other works. Okay.

 Jewish blending AU's, where clans are mixed? WHOA, WHOA, WHY DO YOU HATE TAOISTS AND CHINESE PEOPLE?

 What? Excuse me? How is that – there isn't even any erasure here? There's BLENDING of cultures??

 Oh, I'm sorry, the other culture is Jewish. Right, right, sorry. My bad, I'm sure they didn't mean to get their Jewish hands all over your media and dirty it up.

 Oh, you think that isn't the problem? Please show me other fics that have been dogpiled and then deleted for being, say, Modern AU's taking place in America. That's a huge tag. I'll wait.

 How about the huge number of American Christian AU's? That's a huge tag too. Those are replacing the Chinese culture with American culture, so those HAVE to be bad too, right?

 Oh, they're not? Some of the biggest names dragging Jewish fans through the mud and saying they can't write or do art here have written those kind of AU's?

 Okay, okay, we can leave the actual FICs out of it, you're right we don't want to direct hate towards those authors, esp since they don't have any haters right now.

 How about huge tumblr posts about how problematic those AU's are to the Chinese diaspora fans and also mainland Chinese fans in English fandom? I'm sure those exist, after all I can think of at least one HUGE tumblr post all about Jewish AU's being vastly problematic.

 No? Those don't exist either?

 Oh, ok.

 I get it.

 My bad. It was the Jewish thing, wasn't it?

Profile

themoosejthm: (Default)
Michi

April 2025

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
1314 1516171819
20212223242526
27282930   

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 23rd, 2025 11:08 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios